Aviation

Emirates ordered to pay $5,000 in damages after suitcase fell on passenger’s head

A man has been awarded $5,000 in damages after a suitcase fell on his head during an Emirates flight in 2019.

Stephen Bradshaw took legal action against the airline in December 2019, initially seeking $43,600 in damages ranging from loss of employment to out-of-pocket expenses, under the Montreal Convention.

The incident occurred on 1 January 2019 when Bradshaw, who was 28 at the time, was travelling on an Emirates flight from Dublin to Dubai on his way to Brisbane.

According to court documents, Bradshaw said another passenger opened the overhead luggage bin directly above him as the aircraft banked, causing a child’s suitcase to fall on Bradshaw’s head.

The passenger, Joseph Langan, said the suitcase was “almost empty”, and had mostly been used to carry his daughter’s stuffed animals.

Bradshaw claimed he suffered serious injuries as a result of the incident, which left him “severely dazed” and seeing “a few black spots”.

Upon landing in Dubai, he approached the Emirates desk and asked to be upgraded, but was advised there was not much they could do aside from sending him to hospital.

During his flight from Dubai to Brisbane, Bradshaw said he told flight attendants about the pain in his head and was allowed to lay in the aisle near the toilets, and was given oxygen and panadol before being allowed to sit in the first-class cabin for landing.

Once in Brisbane, Bradshaw claimed he saw a doctor out of concern for his injuries; however, the doctor’s notes didn’t mention a head injury and said he was treated for a sore throat and fever.

He drove to Sydney on 6 January to return to work, with payslips revealing he worked full-time from 8 January.

Bradshaw emailed Emirates on 21 January expressing his disappointment with how he was treated following his injury; however, according to court documents, he made no complaint of lasting injury.

On Friday, Justice Angus Stewart said the evidence gave him the impression that Bradshaw had “embellished” his version of events to support his claim.

“Once he had recorded that embellished version in his email of 21 January 2019, it was difficult for him to resile from it and it got reproduced in his affidavit,” Stewart said.

“The terms of that email indicate that its objective was to try and secure an upgrade or a discount on a future flight because Mr Bradshaw was “displeased … with the treatment [he] received from the airline”; it was not because, as claimed by him in his affidavit, he “was still concerned about [his] ongoing injury to [his] neck and the continuous pain and aching and difficulties at work”. Those matters are not even mentioned in the email.”

Stewart awarded Bradshaw $5,000 in damages for “pain and suffering” after judging that his “loss of amenities of life” were limited.


Featured image source: iStock/structuresxx



SEE WHAT PEOPLE ARE SAYING

Leave a Reply

Events

Collette wraps up its first travel forum in two years

The tour operator hosted top sellers, partners, key travel players and media friends (that’s us!) for poolside shenanigans in sunny Cairns.

Share

CommentComments

Wholesalers

“Travel is the great educator”: Collette CEO Dan Sullivan on why we need travel now more than ever

We spent the past few days sipping mojitos by the pool in Cairns… Oh, and attending Collette’s travel forum! Here’s proof we were listening.

Share

CommentComments

Travel Agents

“It’s our shout”: Flight Centre is giving away free holidays!

The travel giant is giving away 40 holidays to celebrate its 40th Birthday! Nobody tell them that it’s usually the other way around…

Share

CommentComments

Hotels

QT Newcastle signature restaurant and bar revealed!

It might seem like we’re calling Newcastle a ‘cutie’ but rest assured, our cutest NSW city award still goes to Griffith.

Share

CommentComments

Events

Australian Tourism Exchange 2022 concluded and next year’s location revealed!

The rumours are that next year’s event will have twice as many arancini balls and half the day will be dedicated to playing Mario Kart. Bear in mind our source for this was a 6 year old boy…

Share

CommentComments

Destinations

Japan gets closer to reopening its border with experimental group tours

Don’t worry, the fact that the tours are operating is what makes them experimental. You won’t have to remember your high school science skills for a trip to Japan (at least we don’t think so).

Share

CommentComments

Travel Agents

Do you want to explore South Australia? Complete a few training modules for your chance at a famil!

The team at South Australian Tourism Commission has your next holiday sorted with a famil offering for travel agents and product managers.

Share

CommentComments

Tourism

ATEC tickled pink with Labor Party tourism funding promise

As professional journalists, we at Travel Weekly remain completely unbiased when it comes to political matters. However, we’re just going to leave this here…

Share

CommentComments

Tourism

“The time is right”: industry legend, Barry Mayo, retires after 60+ years in travel

We think we speak for everyone when we say we can’t imagine an Australian travel industry without this industry stalwart!

Share

CommentComments

Tourism

Tourism Western Australia partners with AAT Kings and showcases WA wildlife to Sydney

Rumours are that part of the collaboration deal is that the AAT execs all get free camel rides whenever they want, which we completely understand.

Share

CommentComments

Cruise

Humans of Antarctica

Travel Weekly joined Aurora Expeditions for an Antarctic circle expedition and met some amazing travellers who waited over two years for the adventure.

Share

CommentComments

Travel Agents

Flight Centre scores whopping government contract

Work for Flight Centre? Your tax dollars could now be contributing to your own salary, according to our vague understanding of the ATO.

Share

CommentComments