Ruby Princess inquiry: Passengers disembarked before COVID-19 test results to catch flights
A NSW Health physician has told a special inquiry the department decided not to wait for COVID-19 swab results before allowing Ruby Princess passengers to disembark.
According to ABC News, the state’s Chief Human Biosecurity Officer, Dr Sean Tobin, said the decision was made so that passengers from the ship, which has become Australia’s largest source of coronavirus infections, could catch their flights.
When the Ruby Princess docked at Sydney’s Circular Quay in March, around a dozen COVID-19 swabs had been taken, but 2,600 passengers were allowed to disembark as the samples were taken to a lab, the inquiry heard.
Dr Tobin was pressed on why that risk was taken by public health administrators, given the inconvenience to passengers of waiting for the results would have been a matter of around six hours.
Commissioner Bret Walker SC said it could not have been about money, nor the commercial interests of cruise ships, as reported by ABC News.
“By elimination, I’m left with a question mark. What is it that was weighing against ‘waiting and seeing’?” the commissioner asked.
“I think it was a concern for the passengers primarily,” Dr Tobin replied.
“What, so they could get home, to their own bed?” Walker asked.
“Well, to their flights,” Dr Tobin said.
At the time of disembarkation, the Ruby Princess was assessed as “low risk” by a panel that included Dr Tobin. At least 22 people on the ship have since died from COVID-19.
Furthermore, the NSW Health review of its handling of the Ruby Princess debacle was savaged by commissioner Walker for including “spin”, “bias” and “weasel words”.
According to ABC News, the undated, anonymously-authored document, which was reportedly mistakenly left marked as “draft” and “confidential”, was ordered by Chief Health Officer Kerry Chant, Dr Tobin said.
The document reportedly claimed influenza was the “likely” cause of illness on board, despite only half of the 48 flu tests returning a positive result.
Commissioner Walker slammed the report’s “spin” as Dr Tobin insisted it was meant to be an “honest” account of the process.
“Let me be blunt,” Mr Walker said.
“Spin is a form of dishonesty. Half-truth perhaps. Weasel words, certainly. But all with a bias to producing a particular intended effect on the reader, regardless of the merits.
“Something that an impartial public servant would have nothing to do with. Do you agree?”
Dr Tobin conceded the wording could have been improved, according to ABC News.
The document claimed, “the risk assessment process balanced the level of risk against the benefit of removing passengers from a cruise ship on which the virus could be circulating”.
Dr Tobin conceded that was an inaccurate account of the process.
“What can you tell me concerning the possibility that this is a document which is unmeritoriously assembling ex post facto excuses, regardless of whether they are true or false?” Walker asked.
“I don’t think that was the intention of the report,” Dr Tobin replied, as reported by the public broadcaster.
In its “key points”, the document reportedly referred to overseas experiences that showed home isolation was “a much safer option” than leaving passengers on a ship, which commissioner Walker considered “distracting PR”.
The inquiry is set to resume on Monday.
News of the special inquiry comes as Princess Cruises prepares to face two fresh lawsuits alleging the cruise line did not take adequate steps to protect passengers on the Ruby Princess and Grand Princess.
According to USA Today, the lawsuits allege that the cruise line failed to adequately screen for COVID-19 during the boarding process aboard both ships, and then did not act fast enough to impose a quarantine when cases were discovered.
“This is part of a bigger picture of how terribly mismanaged the whole coronavirus outbreak was by the entire cruise industry,” Michael Winkleman, the Miami-based attorney whose firm filed both suits in US District Court in California, told USA Today, adding the virus spread “because of failure to act reasonably and promptly”.
The suits, which are among several that have already been filed, seek class-action status for passengers aboard both the Grand Princess and Ruby Princess.
In an email to USA Today, Princess Cruises said it would not comment on pending litigation, but that it has been “sensitive to the difficulties the COVID-19 outbreak has caused to our guests and crew.”
The cruise line added: “Our response throughout this process has focused on the well-being of our guests and crew within the parameters dictated to us by the government agencies involved and the evolving medical understanding of this new illness.”
Travel Weekly has contacted Princess Cruises for comment.
Featured image: iStock/Photoservice
Email the Travel Weekly team at traveldesk@travelweekly.com.au
coronavirus COVID-19 cruise line grand princess NSW Health princess cruises Ruby PrincessLatest News
Linkd appoints Carolyn Nightingale and Lawson Dibb to new roles
Linkd Tourism sings praises of Carolyn Nightingale and dubs Lawson Dibb as Kyushu Tourism Office guru.
Celebrity Ascent makes its European debut
Choosing to cruise this northern summer? Celebrity Ascent promises to raise the bar.
NCL opens sales for Norwegian Sun’s APAC debut, announces 14 new voyages
It was to be 13 new voyages we heard, but given the numbers unlucky nature, an extra had to be thought up.
Inside Travel Group appoints Tom Welland Global Trade Marketing Manager
Heidi's Tom Welland heads to Inside Travel Group as its new Global Trade Marketing Manager.
Federal Government rolls out $1.4m program to promote careers in tourism across regional NSW
The Government taking a break from some of its pointier issues with some work in our incredible industry!
Australian visitors to South Korea surge
Japanned out? Aussies are adding South Korea to their bucket list.
G Adventures celebrates Dr. Jane Goodall’s 90th with new wildlife-focused trips
Fancy yourself as a bit of a conservationist? Put your skills to the test on the Jane Goodall collection.
Virgin Australia says suspended flights to Bali result of Boeing MAX delays
If only we had a company like Boeing to blame our mistakes on. Any takers? Get in touch!
Airline Review: Singapore Airlines Business Class – A380-800
The iconic Singapore Airlines' A380-800 is in a class of its own - business class that is.
South African Airways to relaunch Joburg – Perth flights as economic ties strengthen
Bringing two of the world's most distinctive accents closer together, for good or for bad is yet to be determined.
My journey: Before becoming a travel agent I was… a palliative care nurse
Australind Travel & Cruise, Travellers Choice member Saibra Twigg reveals her life as paediatric nurse then to palliative care before a career leap to travel agent. How did you become a palliative care nurse? ST I went straight from school in nursing and initially specialised in paediatrics, working at Perth’s Princess Margaret Hospital for Children. […]
Emirates unveils future plans with new hub at Al Maktoum International Airport
We've also been looking into our future. It involves plenty of famils, we hope.
Australia fails to make top 10 destination list for American travellers
Australia's top cities have failed to make the grade with American travellers this northern summer, with no local city in the top.
APT Launches 2025 Asia Adventures
APT has launched its Asia Adventures for 2025, including new luxury holidays in India, Sri Lanka and Japan. Five new tours lead guests to the highlights of India, including a seven-night cruise along the rarely travelled Lower Ganges aboard the Ganges Voyager. Further south, Sri Lanka’s greatest destinations are revealed on a new 15-day Land […]
ANZAC Battlefield travel on the 2025 bucketlist
As Anzac Day dawns, agents prepare for a surge in bookings for the 110th anniversary of the Anzac Cove landings.
Former Channel 9 Getaway host and founder of TRIBE Jules Lund to speak at Travel DAZE
From blond-tipped travel reporter to Travel DAZE speaker, Jules Lund cuts through the BS.
HX’s Roald Amundsen finds aliens in the Antarctic
Forget whales, HX's MS Roald Amundsen captures aliens in the Antarctic - and they're not pretty.
Mayhem in France as 70% of flights face cancellation
I mean it wouldn't be France if there wasn't at least one strike.
Etihad Airways launches double-decker service with world’s only in-air three-room suite
We imagine falling asleep in the three-room suite is superior to falling asleep on your neighbour's shoulder.
Norwegian Cruise Line launches 2024 Europe travel season
Europe certainly has a lot of ports. Its time for Australia to up its game.
“The power of travel for positive change” – Intrepid’s Jenny Gray hails controversial all-women Saudi Arabia trip
There is an awful lot to love about this tour from Intrepid. Where do we sign up?
Princess names the Sun, unveils Sanctuary Collection + Star Princess to Alaska in ’26
A huge bottle of Veuve was smashed into the side of the ship to make things official. So no, we couldn't snag a glass.
Collette special offers across peak northern summer season
If you are craving a trip to Europe then grab this deal with both of your grubby hands.
Air India and All Nippon codeshare between the two countries
Here at TW we agreed that the photo would have worked better if they had swapped planes.
A&K offers minimum 18 weeks paid parental leave
Contrary to what the photo suggests this benefit is only applicable for humans. Back to work Mrs Jumbo.
NH Hotel Group rebrands as Minor Hotels Europe & Americas
Hang around the bends of the hotels. We imagine they will be full of a lot of branded content.
Scenic Eclipse II – the business of creating unforgettable life-changing memories
These cruise brothers from another mother offer a view of cruising on Scenic Eclipse II that is poles apart.
MSC builds new hospital ship with Mercy Ships
If you want to read a story that puts a smile on your face then this is the one for you.
“I peed on myself watching this” – Social media users squirm at Royal Caribbean’s Harmony of The Seas 55ft dive video
TW is not responsible for any involuntary actions your body might have after watching this video.
FLIGHT REVIEW: Qantas Boeing 787 Dreamliner business class
The real bonus is you're unlikely to be around screaming children. Hoorah!
Traveltek offers travel agents new rapid deploy cruise website
As always, if you have any issue with the platform, just turn it off and on again.
Experience whale watching & classical music at the Australian Festival of Chamber Music in Townsville
Disappointedly, the whales do not start singing in tune with the orchestra. Opportunity missed.
Fond, very Fond. London hotel famed for James Bond link adds ‘Classic Comforts’ lunch menu
James Bond author Ian Fleming was so fond if this hotel, it inspired the legendary phrase ‘shaken, not stirred’.
What sets Eclipse Travel apart with Africa expert Hilary Dubyk: Travel Weekly TV
If you want to know more about Africa, then Hilary Dubyk is your person.
Surge in Australians visiting Japan
Feel like all of your friends have just returned from Europe? Now it's Japan.
Seabourn announces Western Kimberley Traditional Owners as Godparents of Seabourn Pursuit
Seabourn has named Western Kimberley Traditional Owners, the Wunambal Gaambera, as Godparents of the ultra-luxury purpose-built Seabourn Pursuit. It is the first cruise line to appoint Traditional Owners as godparents of a ship. Seabourn Pursuit embarks on its inaugural season in the Kimberley region this June. The naming ceremony will take place on Seabourn Pursuit’s […]