Passenger wins damages for “disappointment and distress” from Scenic river cruise

Scenic Diamond, Bordeaux, Pont de Pierre, France

A cruise passenger has been awarded damages for “disappointment and distress” after his luxury cruise turned into a bus tour.

David Moore and his wife were seeking compensation from Scenic Tours after their European river cruise was disrupted by flooding in 2013.

Court documents reveal Moore and his wife spent their life savings of $18,000 on the cruise, as they were attracted to having the ability to travel without the restrictions of confined spaces as he had previously undergone spinal surgery and found it difficult to sit for extended periods.

High water levels on the Rhine and Main Rivers meant that the cruise started on a different vessel and was met with substantial disruptions including changing ships three times and spending many hours on busses. Moore and his fellow passengers spent three days on a cruise ship instead of the advertised 10.

Moore was part of a class action against Scenic involving 1,500 other passengers who experienced disruptions on various other cruises run by the company.

Justice Peter Garling found Scenic Tours had breached Australian consumer law by not specifically warning passengers about weather disruptions.

He said the tour company “played down the significance of what was occurring on the rivers in Europe” and that the company should have given passengers the option to postpone or cancel their trip.

On 24 April Moore was awarded damages for “disappointment and distress” after the high court upheld his appeal for compensation.

The ruling could set a president for other passengers affected by disruptions to travel, including the other passengers involved in the class action against Scenic Tours.

According to ABC News, Moore’s solicitor Ben Hemsworth said the ruling was a “victory for all consumers who have experienced ruined holidays”.

“If consumers are supplied with a disappointing and inadequate substitute, they will be entitled to compensation,” he said.

Meanwhile, in October 2019, the NSW supreme court determined passengers from 14 Scenic cruises in 2018 who were also affected by water levels could have a case against Scenic Tours and ordered the company to provide documents to help determine how many Australian passengers were affected.

Somerville Legal, the firm representing the passengers, said Scenic Tours will launch an appeal.

“In view of the judgments for the 2013 “cruises” it is hard to imagine how they could win,” the firm said on its website.

Travel Weekly has approached Scenic for comment.

Latest News

  • Aviation

Low-cost Indian carrier SpiceJet continues to burn cash

It’s not just low-cost Australian carriers that are facing hardship. SpiceJet, India’s version of Bonza, recently announced a 72 per cent reduction in its net loss versus last year. But, despite this improvement, the airline has posted losses for six straight years. But it has secured board approval to raise up to INR 30 billion […]

  • Attractions

SAKA Museum recognised in TIME magazine’s World’s Greatest Places 2024

AYANA Resort Bali’s newly-opened cultural and events centre, SAKA Museum has been recognised in TIME magazine’s World’s Greatest Places list for 2024. Part of AYANA Bali’s resort destination, the museum integrates Bali’s rich history with state-of-the-art facilities, making it the centrepiece for the island’s spiritual and cultural heritage. TIME magazine’s inclusion of SAKA Museum in […]

  • Cruise

Silversea taps Barbara Biffi as senior vice president for global sales

Ultra-luxury and expedition cruise travel brand, Silverseas, has announced Barbara Biffi as its new senior vice president of global sales. Biffi joined the company in 2007, holding numerous positions and gaining a deep understanding of the brand, the preferences of its guests and its strategic goals, the company said. An Italian national with a wealth […]

  • Technology
  • Travel Agents

Amadeus welcomes FCM Travel as new reseller partner of Cytric Easy

Cytric Easy, the travel management tool embedded in Microsoft Teams, is to be integrated into FCM Travel portfolio. Amadeus and FCM Travel have extended their Cytric distribution agreement to include Cytric Easy. With this new agreement, global travel management company FCM Travel, becomes a reseller of the innovative travel management collaboration solution embedded into Microsoft […]