Double stacking ships can “deliver better guest experience”: cruise advocate

Double stacking ships can “deliver better guest experience”: cruise advocate
By Hannah Edensor


In the wake of recent suggestions that cruise ships dock at Garden Island and Botany Bay, another option has been floated. Yes, another cruise pun. We can’t help ourselves. Sorry.

Richard Davey, Manager at an agency specialising in premium and luxury cruise, and advocate for the cruise industry on the whole, spoke to Travel Weekly about his views.

Davey participated in the IPART review commissioned by then NSW Premier Mike Baird last year. The review was aimed at investigating ways to maximise the use of “existing facilities” in Sydney.

He asked for the review to investigate ways that we could maximise the use of the existing facilities, and that was my suggestion in response.

In response to the review, Davey put forward the notion of double stacking at the Overseas Passenger Terminal (OPT), a solution which has been rejected already by major cruise lines.

Celebrity Cruises President and CEO of Celebrity Cruises, Lisa Lutoff-Perlo, yesterday said, “None of us are interested in double stacking” as it creates a “terrible experience” for guests.

But Davey disagreed.

“I suggested [in the review] that a cruise line(s) be offered an incentive to trial the [double stacking] concept and that it should involve two ships from the same company.

“Ship 1 does not need to arrive earlier than 6am and Ship 2 does not have to wait until after midnight to leave.

“We have heard many reasons for refusal, but you can be sure the real reason is that the tail is trying to wag the dog in trying to gain access to other facilities.

“When it sinks in that the Navy is not about to vacate Garden Island anytime soon, and that there are reasons why Port Botany won’t work, then perhaps we will see it done.

“As for guest experience, who wants to go to Port Botany? Also, this concept allows for more flexible itinerary planning and therefore can deliver a better guest experience in that regard.”

Davey also told TW that even if ships were permitted to stop at Garden Island, it’d likely still be just one dock available, and that’s just not enough.

Meanwhile, for ships that can still fit under the Harbour Bridge, Davey added there are plenty of possibilities.

“We need to see extra sites reclaimed for their use in order to accommodate overflow e.g. Glebe Island and Barangaroo Central,” he said.

“There is already small ship overflow on numerous days during the peak month of February.

“Currently, overflow is handled by forcing these ships to anchor at Athol Bight near Taronga Zoo. It is a beautiful site to be at anchor.

“However when there are moderate to high winds, tender service must be suspended, and that either affects passengers’ enjoyment of Sydney, and can affect the embarkation and disembarkation operations.

“Large ships face this issue too, but for the smaller ones, this scenario is entirely avoidable.

“Even if cruise ships are permitted at Garden Island, there is likely to be only one dock available.

“In this case, it is likely to be mostly be used by large ships, meaning that the needs of the growing fleet of small ships will still need to be considered West of the bridge.

“If the Navy does not allow cruise ships at Garden Island, then the few small ships we still see at the OPT will also be forced under the bridge.

“I would like to see cruise ships at Garden Island as much as anyone else. However the constant lobbying and beating of drums is inappropriate.

“I believe that we could have seen more cruise ship calls to Garden Island over the last few years already with more to come in the future, had negotiations been handled better and directed in the right way with better understanding between the parties.”

Email the Travel Weekly team at traveldesk@travelweekly.com.au

    Latest comments

    1. Thank you for your reply Richard. It just seems the logical solution to me. Cruise ship passengers want to come into Sydney Harbour and see the Harbour Bridge and the Opera House. They don’t want to be out at Botany Bay. Move the Ferries to Barangaroo and build a new world class Overseas Passenger Terminal at Circular Quay, that could handle 3 or 4 ships at the one time.
      The_Appraiser, Hotel Evaluations.

    3. Not sure if there is enough room at Botany Bay and the most likely site to berth a cruise ship there is extremely close to the Southern end of the 3rd runway. Royal and Celebrity’s ships are so tall that they may contravene airspace restrictions.

    4. There is certainly some merit to that idea, as many ferry commuters work in the financial centre of Sydney which is now very well connected underground to Barangaroo and the financial epicentre has now shifted west towards Barangaroo anyway.

    5. I’m not sure Mr Davey is aware of the logistics involved in a cruise ship turnaround. For a “medium” sized ship of around 2,500 guests arriving to Sydney’s OPT at, say 6am, there is no way this ship could be turned around for passengers and stores to depart before 3:30 or 4:00pm. Let’s say minimum 9/12 hours is required for debark, embark, luggage and stores on this size of ship to be generous. And, remember that we have ships of 3,500 people docking these days, which means logistical requirements are even more time consuming.

      So, depending on the time that first ship could get out, and subject to the 2nd ship getting in before harbour curfew on a week day (from my understanding would need to be docked by 4 or 4:30pm or will then be required to wait until after peak hour at 6:30pm), the 2nd ship – if the same size – would then not be out until at least 1 – 1:30am at the earliest (or 3.30am if docking at 6:30pm). Not sure where Mr Davey’s logic is coming from, as his reasoning of “after 6am and before midnight” just doesn’t double stack…

    6. Why can’t the Ferry terminal at Circular Quay be moved to Barangaroo, so the cruise ships can use all of the Circular Quay area with a redesigned overseas terminal built at Circular Quay, with 3 or 4 ship unloaders? Ships could dock on both sides of Circular Quay and possibly in the centre too. Extend the city circle line to include a train station at Barangaroo or just wait for the proposed Metro station. Problem solved for the long term.

botany bay garden island overseas passenger terminal richard davey sydney

Latest News

  • Aviation

Low-cost Indian carrier SpiceJet continues to burn cash

It’s not just low-cost Australian carriers that are facing hardship. SpiceJet, India’s version of Bonza, recently announced a 72 per cent reduction in its net loss versus last year. But, despite this improvement, the airline has posted losses for six straight years. But it has secured board approval to raise up to INR 30 billion […]

  • Attractions

SAKA Museum recognised in TIME magazine’s World’s Greatest Places 2024

AYANA Resort Bali’s newly-opened cultural and events centre, SAKA Museum has been recognised in TIME magazine’s World’s Greatest Places list for 2024. Part of AYANA Bali’s resort destination, the museum integrates Bali’s rich history with state-of-the-art facilities, making it the centrepiece for the island’s spiritual and cultural heritage. TIME magazine’s inclusion of SAKA Museum in […]

  • Cruise

Silversea taps Barbara Biffi as senior vice president for global sales

Ultra-luxury and expedition cruise travel brand, Silverseas, has announced Barbara Biffi as its new senior vice president of global sales. Biffi joined the company in 2007, holding numerous positions and gaining a deep understanding of the brand, the preferences of its guests and its strategic goals, the company said. An Italian national with a wealth […]

  • Technology
  • Travel Agents

Amadeus welcomes FCM Travel as new reseller partner of Cytric Easy

Cytric Easy, the travel management tool embedded in Microsoft Teams, is to be integrated into FCM Travel portfolio. Amadeus and FCM Travel have extended their Cytric distribution agreement to include Cytric Easy. With this new agreement, global travel management company FCM Travel, becomes a reseller of the innovative travel management collaboration solution embedded into Microsoft […]