Wholesalers

The Excite Holidays administrators’ report is out. Here’s everything you need to know

Huntley Mitchell

Huntley Mitchell

The administrators appointed by Excite Holidays have released their much-anticipated report to creditors on the wholesaler’s collapse.

To get you up to speed with the confusing web of companies associated with Excite, here’s a brief explainer:

  • Global Travel Holdings (GTH) is the holding company for Excite Holidays Australia (EHA), Global Travel Specialists (GTS) and Events NG (ENG).
  • GTH is owned jointly by entities controlled by the directors. Travel Serv Co (TSC) is a standalone entity which is owned by the directors.
  • EHA was the main operating entity in Australia, with TSC acting as the service and employing entity for all Australian-based employees.
  • GTS was the former operating entity and ENG held a limited number of contracts and leases.
  • GTH was the holding company and is the registered owner of the office premises. Other than its capacity as landlord of the office premises, it did not undertake any operating activities on behalf of the Excite Holidays business.

The directors’ take

The companies’ directors, Nicholas Stavropoulos and George Papaioannou, provided a number of reasons for Excite’s collapse, according to the report.

One of those was a decline in performance from the second half of FY19 onwards as a result of the business leaving ATAS in December 2018.

Stavropoulos and Papaioannou claim steps were taken to strengthen the companies’ balance sheet and enable Excite to re-join ATAS.

These included undertaking a cost reduction program in the second half of FY19, including reducing its staff headcount from 220 to 132; and engaging a corporate advisor start exploring exploring a part sale of the business or strategic partnership.

According to the directors, these steps did not proceed quickly enough, with committed system development expenses weighing heavily on the cost base.

Further, Stavropoulos and Papaioannou noted an unsuccessful commercial deal with a US-based investor took considerable time and compromised Excite’s trading position further, leaving them with no alternative but to enter into voluntary administration.

The administrators’ take

The preliminary view of KPMG’s Morgan Kelly, Phil Quinlan and Amanda Coneyworth is that there were a number of other reasons why the companies failed.

These include poor financial management of the business during the previous CFO’s tenure (prior to December 2018) and high operating costs associated with the companies’ Australian and global operations.

The administrators also pointed to high levels of capital expenditure, particularly in relation to development of the companies’ proprietary software platform, and insufficient working capital from the companies’ rapid revenue decline following withdrawal from ATAS scheme, resulting in significant losses.

Insolvency and business sale

Kelly, Quinlan and Coneyworth believe the companies, with the exception of GTH, were likely to have become insolvent from late December 2019 to early January 2020.

This was when “a major supplier commenced mass booking cancellations on 24 December 2019, creating severe disruptions to trading and loss of travel agent support of the business; and advanced discussions with a prospective investor stalled on 9 January 2020”.

“Those discussions had previously contemplated the provision of funding in December 2019 to sustain the companies’ operations,” the report said.

“In respect to GTH, the administrators have formed the view that it was not insolvent and recommend that the voluntary administration of this entity should end.”

Immediately following their appointment, the administrators commenced an “urgent process” for a sale of the companies’ proprietary online booking platform.

According to the report, 17 parties expressed initial interest; eight non-disclosure agreements were executed by interested parties, who were given access to the data room; and three interested parties submitted non-binding expressions of interest by the deadline of 19 January.

“The administrators have entered into exclusivity with a preferred party and their due diligence is at an advanced stage,” the report said.

“We anticipate that a further update on the sale will be available at the second meeting of creditors.”

Returns to creditors

The administrators have received a been provided with a pooled deed of company arrangement (DOCA) proposal by Stavropoulos and Papaioannou for their companies (excluding GTH).

Under the proposed DOCA, “priority employees” are expected to receive a dividend of 90 to 100 cents in the dollar, while unsecured creditors are estimated to receive between zero and two cents.

Secured creditors (in this case, the National Australia Bank) will be paid in full pending settlement of the sale of GTH’s premises, which is expected to occur on 30 April 2020.

The DOCA proposal put forward by Excite’s directors has been backed by the administrators, “as it provides a more certain and potentially higher return to unsecured creditors than an orderly liquidation of the DOCA companies’ assets”.

As an alternative to the DOCA proposal recommended by the administrators, creditors may resolve that all companies minus GTH be placed into liquidation.

“Based on our preliminary investigations, we have not identified any additional recoveries which may be available to a liquidator,” the administrators said.

“On this basis, our view is that unsecured creditors will not be likely receive any return in a liquidation scenario.”

To date, the administrators have received 83 proofs of debt totalling $11.3 million from travel agents and suppliers.

Travel agents are predominantly based in Australia; however, some are located overseas, including New Zealand).

Based on the invoicing arrangements within the booking platform, the report said Aussie agents may have traded with EHA and/or the Singaporean entity within the Excite group, Excite Holidays Pte Ltd.

Given this, the preliminary view of administrators is that Aussie agents with outstanding commissions, rebates, refunds and/or unpaid books may be a potential creditor of EHA, and agents based overseas are not creditors of EHA or any other Australian entity.

For agents based in New Zealand, the terms and conditions and invoicing arrangements suggest that they traded with the Kiwi entity and/or the Singaporean entity of Excite.

What happens next?

The second creditors meeting will be held on Monday 17 February 2020 in Sydney, where creditors will decide the companies’ future by voting on one of the following options: that the administration should end (in this case, control of the relevant company will revert to its directors); that the relevant company(ies) should be wound up; or that the relevant company(ies) execute a DOCA.

Feature image: iStock/cyano66

SEE WHAT PEOPLE ARE SAYING

Leave a Reply

Tourism

The Travel Industry Hub creates online community

Are you sick of attending webinars where everyone leaves straight after they end, leaving no chance to network and chat? Well, TTIH is doing something about it.

Share

CommentComments

Aviation

Brisbane Airport achieves global COVID-safe accreditation

While the health and safety protocols at Brisbane’s quarantine hotels are being questioned, at least the airport’s got it together.

Share

CommentComments

Hotels

Nail-biting images emerge of youths taking selfies on Sydney hotel ledge

Bloody kids these days and their death-defying selfies. Back in our day, the cameras were so big that we’d be lucky to get one up a staircase, let alone onto the ledge of a building.

Share

CommentComments

Destinations

South Australia changes border restrictions for travellers from NSW

by Huntley Mitchell

Finding it hard to follow of all the constantly-changing domestic border restrictions? Travel Weekly has done some of the deciphering for you here.

Share

CommentComments

Cruise

Royal Caribbean extends cruise suspension, announces US$40m funding pool for agents

Despite what the headline suggests, the cruise group isn’t offering agents to take a dip in a literal pool of cash, much to our disappointment.

Share

CommentComments

Wholesalers

The Travel Corporation’s Aussie CEO to depart as part of major exec changes

Here’s some very big news right here for your Friday, with TTC’s Fiona Dalton set to fly the coop after just three months in the top role.

Share

CommentComments

Aviation

Indonesian socialite books out entire flight to Bali to avoid COVID-19

The grandson of a pharmaceutical tycoon reckons booking out an entire commercial flight is cheaper than chartering a private jet.

Share

CommentComments

Hotels

Opening date revealed for W Melbourne

Have you been waiting with bated breath for Marriott to reveal the opening date for its new Melbourne property? Well, you can now rid yourself of all that anxiety.

Share

CommentComments

Travel Agents

CTM boss in legal stoush with Brisbane City Council over $20 million property plan

Jamie Pherous has become entangled in a legal battle with the council over a swimming pool he wants to build at his new property on Brisbane River.

Share

CommentComments

Wholesalers

Get in quick! Trafalgar launches ‘Break Out & Break Free’ sale

It appears 2021 is the year of the sale, with Trafalgar joining the already long list of travel brands spruiking their discounted wares.

Share

CommentComments

Aviation

Unions take Qantas to High Court over JobKeeper “wage theft”

by Ali Coulton

Having lost on appeal in the Federal Court late last year, the unions are now taking their JobKeeper fight against Qantas to the High Court.

Share

CommentComments

Cruise

Carnival to ditch 19 ships, as company posts $2.8 billion quarterly loss

Carnival Corporation has added another ship to the pile of vessels that it will offload in order to stay afloat beyond the COVID-19 pandemic.

Share

CommentComments