Minister ponders Garden Island review

Minister ponders Garden Island review
By admin


The cruise industry is holding its breath as the minister of defence Stephen Smith considers the possibility of cruise lines sharing Garden Island with the navy.

An independent review, initiated by the government and conducted by Sir Allan Hawke, has been completed and is now with the ministry.

Sir Allan has spend the past seven months consulting with the navy, cruise lines and stakeholders.

Prime minister Julia Gillard is believed to have told Carnival Australia chief executive Ann Sherry that a recommendation is imminent – a comment regarded as positive by Carnival.

“Carnival believes the PM would not have said anything about the review and washed her hands of it if the government was about to deliver an unfavorable recommendation,” one source said.

The cruise line is believed to “hopeful” of a positive outcome.

The navy has consistently dug its heels in over sharing facilities at Garden Island, continually pushing the emotive argument of national security for its unwillingness to share the location with passenger liners.

Cunard liners – the Queen Mary 2, Queen Elizabeth and Queen Victoria – do berth at the facility but only as one-offs. Any further use by cruise lines has been sharply rejected.

A spokesman for the ministry of defense told Travel Today that the report has been delivered to Stephen Smith’s office.

He added: “No decision has been made on when and how the findings of the Independent Review of the Potential Cruise Ship Access to Garden Island will be made public.”

Email the Travel Weekly team at


Latest News

  • Food & Beverage
  • Hotels

Park Proxi Gibraltar Bowral announces partnership with Lotus Dining Group

Renowned Lotus Dining Group will offer a new dining experience at Southern Highlands property, Park Proxi Gibraltar Bowral, Seibu Prince Hotels & Resorts has announced.  Scheduled to open on 1 September, Lotus will bring its acclaimed Asian cuisine to the Southern Highlands with a hyper-local twist. Diners can expect a blend of favourite Lotus dishes […]

  • Hotels

Nozo Hotel Furano announce winter season exclusive package

Nozo Hotel Furano in Hokkaido has announced a special invitation to Aussie and Kiwi travellers with an exclusive winter package, in anticipation of its first anniversary. The hotel are offering a 30 per cent discount on all rooms and breakfasts for seven-night stays or more. The offer marks the hotel’s milestone celebration and ushers in […]

  • Conferences

Melbourne and Geelong convention centres pave the way for accessibility and inclusion

The operators of Melbourne Convention and Exhibition Centre and the future Nyaal Banyul Geelong Convention and Event Centre have taken a significant step towards inclusivity with the launch of their latest Accessibility Action Plan. Welcoming visitors from diverse backgrounds, Melbourne Convention and Exhibition Trust (MCET) is committed to providing safe spaces to connect and engage. […]

  • Cruise
  • News

AmaWaterways celebrates 22nd anniversary with offers on 2025 trips

As AmaWaterways embarks on its 22nd year, the luxury river cruise line has announced a range of savings offers to make river cruising even more accessible to both new and experienced cruisers. Travellers planning ahead can enjoy savings of up to 20 per cent on a range of European itineraries in 2025. Solo travellers also […]