Technology

“Unethically manipulated”: backlash continues from controversial North Face ad campaign

Edward Pollitt

Edward Pollitt

Even after The North Face removed a controversial campaign in which it bragged about ‘gaming’ Wikipedia, many are still not happy with the outdoor apparel brand.

It was a failed attempt in garnering free product placement using Wikipedia pages of popular tourist destinations that saw The North Face land itself in some trouble.

The company replaced images on high-traffic Wikipedia pages of popular tourist destinations with images featuring its products in an effort to place its images at the top of Google searches.

What’s more, it made a video detailing its efforts and gloating the campaign had cost it “absolutely nothing just by collaborating with Wikipedia”.

The North Face quickly backed down when it realised the mess it had made and removed the campaign, but the backlash has continued.

Updating Wikipedia pages with false or misleading information is nothing new.

In fact, it has become somewhat of a practical joke on the web – which is perhaps why The North Face thought the stunt would be well-received.

However, it seems the joke is on The North Face.

Social media has been quick to point out that Wikipedia is run by volunteers, meaning the people that had to edit and replace The North Face’s attempted product placement images were not being paid.

Wikimedia (parent company of Wikipedia) fellow Liam Wyatt had this to say:

Wyatt also publicly reached out to Patagonia – The North Face’s rival – to ask “would you be interested in sharing some photography of beautiful and remote places around the world, to be used on Wikipedia articles? We’d love to collaborate with groups that share our passion for knowledge about our planet.”

After stating The North Face had “unethically manipulated” Wikipedia with the “short-lived marketing stunt”, Wikimedia has called on companies to learn the existing best practices of properly engaging on Wikipedia.

Leo Burnett Tailor Made, the advertising agency responsible for the disastrous campaign, has issued its own statement on the matter.

“We’re always looking for creative ways to meet consumers where they are,” it said.

“We’ve since learned that this effort worked counter to Wikipedia’s community guidelines.”


This article originally appeared on Travel Weekly’s sister title, B&T.

Breaking News

Events

Women in Travel Awards 2019 winners revealed!

The drinks were (and still are) flowing and the gongs were going as Australia’s travel industry honoured the top females working in it at the Women in Travel Awards 2019 in Sydney tonight.

Share

CommentComments

Travel Agents

REVEALED: Winners of Visit California’s STAR shopping spree incentive!

Did you enter Visit California’s recent comp and also happen to be a finalist at the Women in Travel Awards? Well, you could be in for a double dose of good news today!

Share

CommentComments

Hotels

Hotel wrap: Manhattan-inspired hotel coming to Sydney, Chiva-Som to reopen ahead of schedule + MORE

Spend your morning wishing you were staying in a luxury hotel somewhere warm instead of freezing your butt off in Australia? We’ve got you covered.

Share

CommentComments

Aviation

Did Air New Zealand’s CEO resign to pursue a career in politics?

This story was a great excuse for our designer to see what happens when you Photoshop Christopher Luxon’s head on Jacinda Ardern’s body. Voilà!

Share

CommentComments

Aviation

Everything you need to know about Qantas’ biggest-ever frequent flyer overhaul

The airline just pumped $25 million into its loyalty program and, lucky for you, we’ve penned this fabulous explainer. Or typed, rather.

Share

CommentComments

Destinations

New ad campaign encourages Melburnians to find ‘Your Happy Space’ in regional Victoria

Travel Weekly’s editor has found his happy place in the office today – in front of a fire he started in his desk bin with a glass of mulled wine and some s’mores.

Share

CommentComments

Travel Agents

STUDY: Agents are more likely to be purpose-led than any other industry

Congrats, agents! You officially give many more effs than any other industry! We knew you had it in you.

Share

CommentComments

Wholesalers

“Unconscious bias needs to be addressed”: Intrepid CEO James Thornton on gender equality in the industry

We chat to Intrepid’s boss about the gender equality challenges still facing the travel industry, and how the tour operator is playing its part in overcoming them.

Share

CommentComments

Road & Rail

Road & rail wrap: Luxe ride across Rajisthan, Eurostar introduces more Netherlands trips + MORE

To celebrate our commuter train arriving 25 minutes late this morning, we’re bringing you this whopper of a wrap direct from platform 17.

Share

CommentComments

Aviation

MH17 investigators to lay murder charges

The team of investigators also revealed they have proof the Russian Federation was involved in the tragic crime.

Share

CommentComments

Events

FIVE TICKETS LEFT! The Women in Travel Awards kick off tonight

Tonight’s the night, folks! Get your frocks out, strap on your dancing shoes and get ready to celebrate all the great women in our industry.

Share

CommentComments

Aviation

Air New Zealand CEO Christopher Luxon resigns

Christopher Luxon is stepping down from the top job at Air New Zealand amid reports he’s been called up to represent the All Blacks at the Rugby World Cup.

Share

CommentComments