Scenic to “appeal court decision” over class action payout
Scenic could be forced to pay up to $16 million in damages and fares to customers in a massive class action case.
More than 1200 travellers booked on luxury Scenic cruises were served up a very different holiday when extensive rainfall and mass flooding in France and Germany in 2013 caused significant river risings.
The consequence of the flooding meant river cruises were unable to navigate the torrential waters as per usual. However Scenic didn’t cancel the trips, as many other operators did, but rather operated tours via buses instead.
In the NSW Supreme Court yesterday, Justice Peter Garling found Scenic breached the Australian consumer law, per ABC, by not informing passengers about the severe weather disruptions.
He said the tour company “played down the significance of what was occurring on the rivers in Europe”.
He added that by downplaying the disruptions, Scenic concealed the company’s “internal position that it would offer a full refund for guests on the identified cruises if requested”.
Justic Garling said that Scenic should have given customers the option to postpone or cancel their trip, per ABC.
“Scenic had a continuing obligation to provide intending passengers (at least those who had made bookings which had been accepted) with information about events, or the consequences of events, which may have impacted…upon the passenger’s ability to travel in accordance with the itinerary and to enjoy the luxury cruise experience which Scenic had promised.”
But Scenic is disputing the decision, which has seen David Moore lead 1265 participants in the class action, resulting in Moore successfully awarded $13,000.
Most passengers in the class action will, per ABC, be entitled to a refund, damages and interest, after booking what was promised to be a “once in a lifetime luxury river cruise”, which could amount to as much as $16 million.
A Scenic spokesperson told Travel Weekly, “It is important that we review the judgment in detail before making specific comment on the decision.
“Scenic will be appealing the decision handed down yesterday. We note there have been reports of Scenic’s estimated liability for the payout to the class. These estimations are premature and in any event it is important to note that not all cruises were affected in the same way.
“A blanket estimate cannot be drawn from Mr Moore’s individual award.”
In addition to this, Scenic’s spokesperson added, “I can confirm it has always been Scenic’s practice to deliver itineraries as close to schedule as possible without compromising on safety or comfort.
“To put some context around the matter, despite the extraordinary weather conditions in Europe in early 2013, less than five per cent of Scenic cruises in the past four years resulted in any itinerary change.
“During that time we welcomed around 200,000 guests across more than 8,300 cruise days, the vast majority of which were unaffected.
“But while the prospect of schedule interruptions is statistically very low, we take nothing for granted and have continued to invest in our river cruising product.”
Per ABC, Scenic Tours claimed each of the members in the class action signed a contract in which they accepted its terms and conditions.
The contract stated, “Cruise itineraries may be varied due to high or low water levels, flooding…[and] circumstances beyond our control”.
“We may substitute (at the nearest possible standard) another vessel or motorcoach for all or part of the itinerary and also provide alternative accommodation, where necessary.
“Where we make a variation to the itinerary, we are not liable to you for such variations.”
Per ABC, the company was ordered to pay costs, which will be determined at a later date.
Solicitor Ben Hemsworth told the courts, “It’s a group of ordinary Australians who paid a lot of money thinking they were going to get a luxury cruise.
“They didn’t get that, they feel they have been wronged and today they were vindicated by the court.
“They turned up expecting a luxury cruise going from port to port and dining on that cruise liner and they ended up being out on buses and taken to places they were not expecting.
“A lot of the passengers were elderly and wanting to stay in the one place, so having to be moved around by bus was distressing to them.”
Per ABC, the members of the class action argued that Scenic “should have known that the rising river levels would, or were likely to, substantially disrupt, for a period of six weeks thereafter, the enjoyment of passengers scheduled to embark upon river cruises”.
“The plaintiff and group members contend that such knowledge ought to have been known to the defendant as reasonable tour operators conducting business in Europe, being river cruises along European rivers,” the statement of claim said.
The statement said they all suffered loss or damage including the price of the tour, a significant drop in value for the services they were actually delivered, and a lack of opportunity to consider any proposed alternative or receive a refund.
Per SMH, the Scenic ship Moore was on was forced to dock 110 kilometres from Cologne, with passengers transported into town by coach, not returning to the ship until after midnight.
On the fourth day, instead of sailing along the Rhine, they remained docked on the Moselle River in Koblenz, while the fifth day saw passengers take a five-hour round coach into Munich, where they went on a one-hour sightseeing tour by coach, and upon return, told they had to abandon their ship.
The following day was spent on a bus, per SMH, and the rest of the tour resulted in many missed destinations due to docking problems, with long days spent on coaches.
Email the Travel Weekly team at traveldesk@travelweekly.com.au
class action david moore scenic scenic toursLatest News
Holland America Line gives agents the chance to visit Alaska on 11-day Famil
If you've ever wanted to see a Polar Bear (and who doesn't?), now is your time.
More than 65 luxury agents gather in Sydney for Best of the Best dinner
This looks like a fabulous do. We imagine there may be a few (or maybe 65) sore heads this morning!
Globally-renowned chefs gather for Vivid Food 2024
As a human, we agree that food is a fundamental part of the human experience. Some might say the most fundamental.
Air New Zealand returns to Hobart and Seoul
If you notice an uptick in Kiwis making their way through the Mona, you know why.
European Waterways targets multi-generational families with ‘floating villa’ deal
The jury is still out on whether spending a week on a 'floating villa' with family is a hell or a paradise.
Luxury Escapes launches ‘sail away’ sale
Rest assured, you'll be getting your 'sails' and 'sales' mixed up for the rest of the day.
Rex-owned National Jet Express adds weekly charter between Brisbane and Orange
This is for mining and civil contractors, so please, put your holiday attire away.
Let the games begin. Viking introduces eye-watering benefits for the industry’s top 10 advisors
Did someone say 'trip to Venice'? Hold my coat, this one is far too good to miss!
Best friends or frenemies? What is the REAL relationship between sales and marketing?
We can all stop fighting over the corner office because our mothers were right - we are all important in our own way.
The Walshe Group Announces Two Key Appointments
What we really want to know is whether they got joint or separate welcome parties.
FAMIL: Agents explore the delights of Mauritius on 7-day tour
Go green with envy as you read this fabulous itinerary! Time to book that second honeymoon.
Hamad International recognised as world’s best airport at 2024 Skytrax World Airport Awards
Hamad airport is so good it is almost considered a destination in itself. Ballina, up your game.
Saudi Arabia highlights tourism investment opportunities at global investment event
Now is the time to start looking at Saudi Arabia if you are not already. There's big things to come.
“Rampant” – Aussies warned as dengue fever cases spike in Bali
Worried about Bali belly? Now you have something else to worry about.
TTC Tour Brand reveals slew of deals across operators including Trafalgar and Contiki
Everybody loves a bargain and you could do lot a lot worse than check out these deals from TTC!
Fiji Airways partners with Porter Airlines in US growth bid
Any initiative that gets more people visiting the delights of Fiji is a good initiative.
Flight Centre launches CruiseHQ – a marketplace exclusively for agents
The cruise industry has surpassed pre-Covid levels so this isn't one to miss!
Feeling festive? Wendy Wu tours unwraps Christmas collection
Get the Christmas hols booked now and avoid spending it with that elderly relative with dubious political views.
OPINION: In a world of screens, we crave experience
If you get feelings of deep shame and regret when you see your screen time, don't worry - you're not alone.
Sun Princess: High-end dining and world class entertainment awaits
If you are a foodie and you are not currently on the Sun Princess, we really have to ask - what are you doing?
YouGov: 2 in 5 Aussies would pay more for a sustainable hotel
If you want to be REALLY sustainable you can go camping. You just might lose the will to live.
“Can planes swim?” – Planes become boats as Dubai Airport is savaged by severe storm
Unfortunately, "can planes swim?" is a real life question and not an opener to a really bad joke...
Explora journeys reveals bespoke outdoor furniture designed by Matteo Nunziati
This is making your plastic table and chairs look really bad now, isn't it?
Bangkok Airways targets growth with renewed Sabre deal
Two stories abut Sabre's growth in one week and its only Wednesday! Watchout world.
PR agency Example wins pitch for InterContinental Sydney
We also went in for the contract but they said that a 'Be Our Guest'- themed TikTok was unoriginal! The cheek.
Norwegian Cruise Line reveals culinary experience aboard Norwegian Aqua
Once again, this TW journalist REALLY regrets writing this before getting lunch.
Signature Queensland hosts luxury tourism event
Known for its tropical beaches and unique wildlife, Queensland also offers luxury.
Capella Sydney recognised in prestigious Travel + Leisure’s 2024 ‘it list’ of best new hotels
You know that 'it girl' at school who everyone wanted to hang out with? Capella is the hotel version of that.
Rex launches 72-hour fare sale with NO school holiday blackout so you can take your kids (if you want to)
Sadly, leaving your children at home whilst you go on holiday is generally frowned upon.
Adventure World offers chance to connect with “heart and soul” of the US
I mean who hasn't dreamed of a road trip around the US?! Go with Adventure World and you're less likely to get lost.
Fiji’s family-owned luxury resort Likuliku Lagoon launches its own app
We were relieved to find out that having a "concierge in your pocket" referred to an app on your phone.
Hawaii: The US’ laid-back front door for Australians
If you needed another sign that you should definitely head to Hawaii - this is it!
Sabre targets Asia Pacific growth with latest hire
Call the Avengers! Sabre continues its bid for world domination with latest hire.
Air New Zealand signs its largest EVER deal for sustainable aviation fuel
Air New Zealand makes huge step towards sustainable travel. We bet it recycles its rubbish properly too.
IHG Hotels & Resorts continues regional growth with Sunshine Coast Holiday Inn
This Holiday Inn looks considerably flashier than some of the ones we have stayed at in our time.
Budget carrier Scoot welcomes first of 9 E190-E2 aircrafts
Here at TW we would like to offer Embraer E190-E2 a warm welcome! It's not easy being the first of the fleet.