Cruise

Double stacking ships can “deliver better guest experience”: cruise advocate

In the wake of recent suggestions that cruise ships dock at Garden Island and Botany Bay, another option has been floated. Yes, another cruise pun. We can’t help ourselves. Sorry.

Richard Davey, Manager at an agency specialising in premium and luxury cruise, and advocate for the cruise industry on the whole, spoke to Travel Weekly about his views.

Davey participated in the IPART review commissioned by then NSW Premier Mike Baird last year. The review was aimed at investigating ways to maximise the use of “existing facilities” in Sydney.

He asked for the review to investigate ways that we could maximise the use of the existing facilities, and that was my suggestion in response.

In response to the review, Davey put forward the notion of double stacking at the Overseas Passenger Terminal (OPT), a solution which has been rejected already by major cruise lines.

Celebrity Cruises President and CEO of Celebrity Cruises, Lisa Lutoff-Perlo, yesterday said, “None of us are interested in double stacking” as it creates a “terrible experience” for guests.

But Davey disagreed.

“I suggested [in the review] that a cruise line(s) be offered an incentive to trial the [double stacking] concept and that it should involve two ships from the same company.

“Ship 1 does not need to arrive earlier than 6am and Ship 2 does not have to wait until after midnight to leave.

“We have heard many reasons for refusal, but you can be sure the real reason is that the tail is trying to wag the dog in trying to gain access to other facilities.

“When it sinks in that the Navy is not about to vacate Garden Island anytime soon, and that there are reasons why Port Botany won’t work, then perhaps we will see it done.

“As for guest experience, who wants to go to Port Botany? Also, this concept allows for more flexible itinerary planning and therefore can deliver a better guest experience in that regard.”

Davey also told TW that even if ships were permitted to stop at Garden Island, it’d likely still be just one dock available, and that’s just not enough.

Meanwhile, for ships that can still fit under the Harbour Bridge, Davey added there are plenty of possibilities.

“We need to see extra sites reclaimed for their use in order to accommodate overflow e.g. Glebe Island and Barangaroo Central,” he said.

“There is already small ship overflow on numerous days during the peak month of February.

“Currently, overflow is handled by forcing these ships to anchor at Athol Bight near Taronga Zoo. It is a beautiful site to be at anchor.

“However when there are moderate to high winds, tender service must be suspended, and that either affects passengers’ enjoyment of Sydney, and can affect the embarkation and disembarkation operations.

“Large ships face this issue too, but for the smaller ones, this scenario is entirely avoidable.

“Even if cruise ships are permitted at Garden Island, there is likely to be only one dock available.

“In this case, it is likely to be mostly be used by large ships, meaning that the needs of the growing fleet of small ships will still need to be considered West of the bridge.

“If the Navy does not allow cruise ships at Garden Island, then the few small ships we still see at the OPT will also be forced under the bridge.

“I would like to see cruise ships at Garden Island as much as anyone else. However the constant lobbying and beating of drums is inappropriate.

“I believe that we could have seen more cruise ship calls to Garden Island over the last few years already with more to come in the future, had negotiations been handled better and directed in the right way with better understanding between the parties.”

SEE WHAT PEOPLE ARE SAYING

  • Maxwell Smart

    the Navy should simply be told by fed govt to make space. They don’t need to be asked for approval, they are after all lowly public servants.

  • Maxwell Smart

    Botany bay is very close to the airport. Why not use it for some cruises ? Many people fly into SYD to catch a cruise.

  • The_Appraiser

    Why can’t the Ferry terminal at Circular Quay be moved to Barangaroo, so the cruise ships can use all of the Circular Quay area with a redesigned overseas terminal built at Circular Quay, with 3 or 4 ship unloaders? Ships could dock on both sides of Circular Quay and possibly in the centre too. Extend the city circle line to include a train station at Barangaroo or just wait for the proposed Metro station. Problem solved for the long term.

  • Matt Halloran

    I’m not sure Mr Davey is aware of the logistics involved in a cruise ship turnaround. For a “medium” sized ship of around 2,500 guests arriving to Sydney’s OPT at, say 6am, there is no way this ship could be turned around for passengers and stores to depart before 3:30 or 4:00pm. Let’s say minimum 9/12 hours is required for debark, embark, luggage and stores on this size of ship to be generous. And, remember that we have ships of 3,500 people docking these days, which means logistical requirements are even more time consuming.

    So, depending on the time that first ship could get out, and subject to the 2nd ship getting in before harbour curfew on a week day (from my understanding would need to be docked by 4 or 4:30pm or will then be required to wait until after peak hour at 6:30pm), the 2nd ship – if the same size – would then not be out until at least 1 – 1:30am at the earliest (or 3.30am if docking at 6:30pm). Not sure where Mr Davey’s logic is coming from, as his reasoning of “after 6am and before midnight” just doesn’t double stack…

  • Richard Davey

    There is certainly some merit to that idea, as many ferry commuters work in the financial centre of Sydney which is now very well connected underground to Barangaroo and the financial epicentre has now shifted west towards Barangaroo anyway.

  • Richard Davey

    Not sure if there is enough room at Botany Bay and the most likely site to berth a cruise ship there is extremely close to the Southern end of the 3rd runway. Royal and Celebrity’s ships are so tall that they may contravene airspace restrictions.

  • Richard Davey

    The navy won’t be and cannot be pushed around. I also believe this is a very good message for them to send out to our potential enemies!

  • The_Appraiser

    Thank you for your reply Richard. It just seems the logical solution to me. Cruise ship passengers want to come into Sydney Harbour and see the Harbour Bridge and the Opera House. They don’t want to be out at Botany Bay. Move the Ferries to Barangaroo and build a new world class Overseas Passenger Terminal at Circular Quay, that could handle 3 or 4 ships at the one time.
    The_Appraiser, Hotel Evaluations.

Tourism

Flavour of the Week

These new industry appointments are bound to shake up your Friday. Because they’re moving and shaking, get it? Sorry, but it is the end of the week.

Share

CommentComments

Travel Agents

Big Fat Agent Wrap

The agent wraps are our favourite thing to do on a Friday. Well, that and research places to go for lunch. And bars to go to for happy hour. But agent wraps come a close third.

Share

CommentComments

Destinations

Introducing Australia’s most Instagrammable restaurants

Cancel all your weekend plans because you’re going to want to want to eat your way through this delicious list.

Share

CommentComments

Tourism

Big Fat Aloha Friday Wrap

This Aloha Friday wrap is of mammoth proportions! Ok, it’s quite reasonably sized, but it is filled with fire-breathing dragons. Ok, that isn’t true either.

Share

CommentComments

Hotels

PICTURES: Sneak peek at Queensland’s first Westin hotel

Here are some pictures of a very pretty hotel to gaze at while you pretend you’re working. We’ve already wasted half our morning on them.

Share

CommentComments

Travel Agents

“You need to be genuinely interested”: Top selling agent reveals her tips for increasing sales

Sue Wright made $300,000 in her first three months as a PTM! We caught up with her to find out her secrets to success.

Share

CommentComments

Aviation

PASSENGERS REACT: Qantas scraps in-flight music on domestic

If you’re one to engage in mid-flight silent discos, you may want to bring your own beats from now on.

Share

CommentComments

Aviation

“Back to the shop”: Cathay Pacific misspells its own name on livery

The airline has been forced to take one of its planes back to the painters after becoming aware of an embarrassing typo. Look, we’ve all been there.

Share

CommentComments

Aviation

Emirates rumored to be considering Etihad take over

Emirates have denied rumours they are considering taking over Etihad, which would form the world’s biggest airline by passenger traffic.

Share

CommentComments

Tourism

How sustainability, global trends and culture relate to tourism’s future being featured at Hawaii’s Global Tourism Summit

Three areas of focus for tourism’s future – sustainability, global trends and culture – will be addressed by a variety of speakers, panelists and attendees from around the world and within the Hawaiian Islands at Hawaii’s Global Tourism Summit.

Share

CommentComments

Destinations

Hawaii on sale

by Ashlee Galea

Shopping in Hawaii is nothing short of sensational – Hawaii provides American retail therapy with a Pacific island twist.

Share

CommentComments

Tourism

Keynote speakers at Hawaii’s Global Tourism Summit to address the power – and challenges – of Travel’s Future

The theme of this year’s Global Tourism Summit – Charting the Course – points to the ever-present need for destinations and travel suppliers to continuously balance the power of tourism’s popularity worldwide with its impact on residents and communities.

Share

CommentComments